Baseline studies


back

3.1 Introduction
The objective of an ecological assessment as a stand alone process for environmental impact assessment is to provide adequate and accurate ecological baseline information of the area proposed for development and to provide (a) a first hand, specific and updated information on the existing ecological attributes of the proposed development site and its vicinity; (b) verify information obtained from the review of existing information and (c) and fill in existing information gaps on ecological impacts. It is well understood that ecological assessments for EIA differs from an academic study (e.g. autecology of a certain species) in that the latter aims at revealing specific biological information in greater details, while the former is more general in nature, wider in scope and is mainly an attempt towards ecological characterization of the project area. The purpose of such a characterisation is to develop a description of the important ecosystem components, processes and resources in areas identified for project location and their functional relationships. It essentially involves description of the salient features of the ecosystem and wildlife habitats, characterisation and valuation of important habitats (components e.g., breeding, spawning, ranging and migratory areas), the floral and faunal resources present in different habitats and the extent of use of habitats by wild animals. These outputs of ecological baseline become extremely valuable inputs in the evaluation of the magnitude and severity of environmental problems resulting from project induced modification associated with the design and management of synthetic and engineered systems nested within the natural ecosystems.

Although the scope of ecological baseline studies would vary from case to case depending on the wildlife groups to be surveyed efforts were made to structure these studies with due considerations to the duration of survey that would be commensurate with the scale of the proposed development at hand and review of Environmental Impact Assessment Ordinances and practice guidelines developed by professionals worldwide (Bagri and Vorhies 1997; Treweek 1999; Anon., undated).

3.2 An overview of the habitat
The catchment area of the Human River Project is ca. 103300 ha, of which ca. 40% is under the forest department. The forests of the Project area are representative of the Central Indian highland forests (Southern Tropical Dry Deciduous Forest) with Tectona grandis (teak) and as the dominant tree species. Broad valleys merging gradually into gently undulating sand stones towards the north and intermittently into highlands characterize the area. The proposed dam site is at an elevation of ca. 200 – 400 m and the catchment area is fan shaped. Based on available information from the Forest department and other sources, the presence of over 45 common woody plants, 19 herbs, shrubs and climbers and 21 medicinal plants have been reported from the Project area. However, there are no reports of any threatened flora from the area. Other forest habitats like grasslands do not exist within a span of 7 km from the proposed dam. However, there are small plantations of bamboo and teak in the Project area that contribute to structural habitat diversity.

3.3 The status of habitat in the identified thrust areas
3.3.1 The area under proposed submergence

The presence of Tadoba-Andhari Tiger Reserve on the western side of the submergence zone is expected to have a strong influence on the faunal characteristics of the area as there is evidence of presence of various species of wild animals across the forests from the Tiger Reserve towards the Human river and beyond. The submergence area is largely dominated by private and revenue land (75%), with only 25% (1535.85 ha) of the area under forests.

Our assessment was largely confined to the western side of the Human river (towards the TATR), from the village Paarna to the dam site, while walking along the meandering river's curves and at times into the riverine forests.

Baseline Studies

Figure 4

 

Baseline Studies

Plate 1

 

Baseline Studies

Plate 2

 

Baseline Studies

Plate 3

Floral values

Isolated patches of riverine vegetation along the Human river comprises mainly tree species such as Syzygium cumini, Terminalia arjuna, Ficus infectoria, and Mitragyna parvifolia (Plate 1). However, these riverine forests are conspicuous by the absence of representatives of old trees and the smaller patches are generally degraded due to intense human use and livestock grazing. The forests in this area are well wooded in parts with a crown density varying from 0.4 to 0.6.

Faunal values

The fauna of the area is typical of the landscape, which is largely dominated by agricultural fields, with patches of open scrub jungle, and riverine forests. Indirect evidences of ungulates (chital, sambar), sloth bear, large predators (tiger, leopard) and among small mammals, civets were recorded (Plate 2 & 3). The direct sightings of mammals included common langur (> 17 individuals) and a jungle cat (Table 8 & Figure 4). Among birds, the Grey Francolin, Rose-ringed Parakeet, Eurasian Collared-Dove, Indian Roller, Red-vented Bulbul, Indian Robin, Purple Sunbird, Common Myna, and Black Drongo were abundant. The riverine forests commonly reveal presence of ‘forest edge - secondary forest species’ like Shikra, Spotted Dove, Lesser Golden-backed Woodpecker, Common Woodshrike, Small Minivet, Common Iora, Tickell’s Blue Flycatcher, and White-browed Fantail Flycatcher among birds and Mabuya carinata and Calotes versicolor among reptiles. One of the most striking aspects of the birdlife here is the apparent paucity of raptors, despite the presence of a riverine ecosystem. In central India, forests along river courses are generally rich in raptor diversity. However, we encountered only three species of birds of prey viz., Black-shouldered Kite, Black Kite, and Shikra. Among reptiles, the area supported common and habitat generalist species like Varanus bengalnensis, Mabuya carinata, Calotes versicolor, Psammophilius dorsalis, and Sitana ponticeriana. The quality: structure, composition and integrity of riverine forests that arbiter presence of several raptor species like Changeable Hawk-Eagle, Crested Serpent Eagle, Bonelli’s Eagle or the wintering populations of Eurasian Sparrowhawk is lacking. The species diversity of waterbirds (including waders and waterfowl) is also very spectacular, while there were no records of turtles and crocodiles along the section of Human river surveyed.

Anthropogenic pressures

The forests are located in a mosaic of agriculture fields and villages (Zudpi areas or shrub lands) and are under intense anthropogenic pressure as evident from the sparse crown density of 0.2 – 0.5 (Anon., 2001) recorded from the forests neighboring villages. Several instances of wood cutting, water tapping for irrigation purposes and sand mining were recorded in this area. Heavy demands for water, to meet the irrigation needs of the small farmers dotted along the entire stretch of the river and the intensive use of the area by livestock was quite evident. The river itself is reduced to small pools and puddles of water in the dry season. Many of these pools are stagnant and polluted, and therefore are not suitable for supporting significant waterbird populations.

3.3.2 The forest area en route the dam axis
The WII team walked along the entire 3.2 km linear stretch of the dam axis and the following floral and faunal values were recorded.

Floral values

The Reserved Forest through which the dam axis traverses is a mix of dense scrub jungle and dry deciduous forests (Plate 4). Commonly recorded plants of the area were Grewia hirsuta, Pterocarpus marsupium, Madhuca indica, Syzygium cumini, Mitragyna parvifolia, and and shrub layer dominated by Lantana camara. Tall trees typical of the central Indian highlands such as Tectona grandis, Terminalia tomentosa, or Dalbergia paniculata were very few in this area.

Baseline Studies

Plate 4

 

Faunal values

Indirect evidences of ungulates (chital, sambar) sloth bear, large predators (tiger, leopard) and small omnivores like civets were recorded among mammals (Plate 2 & 3). The direct sightings of mammals included a troop (> 10 individuals) of common langur (Table 8 & Figure 5). No endemic or endangered species of birds and reptiles were recorded. The area supported common species of reptiles like Varanus bengalnensis, Mabuya carinata, Calotes versicolor, Psammophilius dorsalis, and Sitana ponticeriana.

Anthropogenic pressures

Although, no villages are located along the orientation of the dam axis, the area is adjoins villages and therefore signs of woodcutting and grazing were commonly observed. The dam axis also cuts across a highway, which would be re-aligned during the Project implementation phase.

3.3.3 The forest area under Left Bank Canal
Added to the Dam, is the fact that an initial section of 1.5 km of the Left Bank Canal is aligned along the Reserve Forest Compartment No. 232 and is likely to fragment the forest and the wild animal populations (Plate 5).

Floral values

The area is largely scrub forest dominated by Lantana camara, Zizyphus oenoplia, and Grewia hirsuta. Here again tall tree species like Tectona grandis Terminalia tomentosa, Anogeisus latifolia and Dalbergia paniculata are almost absent leading to significantly reduced diversity of the forests.

Faunal values

Indirect evidences of ungulates (chital, sambar, nilgai and chowsingha), large carnivores (tiger, leopard), jackals, hyaena, hare, porcupine and civet were recorded among mammals (Plate 2 & 3). The direct sightings included common langurs (Table 8 & Figure 6). The bird community in this habitat is dominated by generalists species like Rose-ringed Parakeet, Purple Sunbird, Red-vented Bulbul, Spotted Dove, Greenish Warbler, and Yellow-throated Sparrows. Reptiles in the area are also represented by habitat generalists species like Calotes versicolor, while no rare and endangered species were recorded.

Anthropogenic pressures

Signs of wood cutting and grazing though not common were occasionally seen.

3.3.4 The area between the TATR and submergence
Floral values

The forests in the submergence zone are a mix of dry deciduous and scrub with an average canopy height of 5 m. The more commonly observed species were Zizyphus oenoplia, Anogeisus latifolia and Grewia hirsuta. Some patches are completely degraded and naturally open with rocky outcrops. Towards the western side (the TATR boundary) the forests gradually change in structure and become denser with well defined bamboo understorey. Trees like Dalbergia paniculata, Tectona grandis, and Terminalia tomentosa were also recorded here (Plate 6).

Faunal values

Indirect evidences of ungulates (chital, sambar), sloth bear, hyaena, large predators (tiger, leopards) and small mammals like civets were recorded (Plate 2 & 3). We also recorded occasional evidences of nilgai and chowsingha Direct sightings involved a troupe of common langur (Table 8 & Figure 7). Among reptiles, the area supports common species like Varanus bengalnensis, Mabuya carinata, Calotes versicolor, and Sitana ponticeriana. No endemic or endangered species were recorded.

 

Baseline Studies

Figure 5

 

Baseline Studies

Plate 5

 

Baseline Studies

Figure 6

Baseline Studies

Plate 6

Anthropogenic pressures

The area is dominated with agriculture fields interspersed with forest patches and many villages such as Sirkada, Vihirgaon, Piparda, Parna, Palasgaon and Gondmohadi. Intense pressure for fuel wood and livestock grazing (Plate 7) lopping and the movement of livestock, are persistent and significant sources of intense biotic pressures.

3.3.5 The likely corridor for animal movement
The area comprises of Reserved Forest Compartment No. 232 of Chandrapur Forest division and Reserved Forest Compartment Nos. 47 and 48 of Bramhapuri Forest division. These provide the vital connectivity to forests in the larger landscape.

Floral values

The terrain is undulating with well wooded forests, dominated by Tectona grandis, Chloroxylon swietenia, Miliusa velutina, Anogeisus latifolia, and Terminalia sp. on drier sites and Boswellia serrata. The shrub layer is dominated by Lantana camara (Plate 8).

Faunal values

Indirect evidences of ungulates such as chital, chowsingha, sambar and wild pig were recorded (Plate 2 & 3). The direct sightings of mammals included a troupe of common langur (Table 8 & Figure 8). Though the bird life was not as diverse as that of the adjacent Protected Area (Tadoba-Andhari Tiger Reserve), it was marginally richer in species composition than the avifauna near Human river. Presence of birds such as Large-tailed Nightjar, Grey Junglefowl, Red Spurfowl, Black-backed Woodpecker, and Brown-capped Pygmy Woodpecker indicate greater diversity of habitat elements. There is an opportunity to manage such areas for larger generalists and versatile species of large carnivores and their prey as the evidence of diverse components are indicative of lower disturbance.

Anthropogenic pressures

Although there are no villages in this area, there is still pressure on this habitat in form of illicit cutting of wood and livestock grazing as the area adjoins villages. This is not an uncommon situation in Indian forests by any means, PA’s notwithstanding.

3.4 Avifaunal assessment of conservation significance in the Project area

The birds of central Indian forests, though not as rich and remarkable as that of Eastern Himalayas or Western Ghats, do comprise a few species of conservation significance at the national and global levels. These include Indian White-backed Vulture, Malabar Pied Hornbill, Forest Owlet, Spotted Grey Creeper, Green Munia, and White-bellied Minivet. We did not encounter any direct or indirect evidences of the presence of these birds in our rapid survey of the areas under the proposed Human River Project. The submergence area of the Project was also not found to have any significant patch of potential habitats for these threatened bird species. During the survey, many species of birds have been recorded and presented in Table 10.

The lists of mammals, birds and reptiles recorded in the different trust areas have been complied and presented in Tables 9, 10 & 11.

Baseline Studies

 

Figure 7

Baseline Studies

Figure 8

Baseline Studies

Plate 7

Baseline Studies

Plate 8

Table 8. Summary of mammal evidences during transect sampling

Transect No. Compartment number(s) surveyed GPS bearings Location of the transect Transect length (straight distance) Evidences Species (numbers)
Transect # 1 232, 234,
262, 258
79 31' 36.90 N
20 18' 00.96 E

79 30' 26.95 N
20 16' 14.47 E

Proposed dam site
(end point
3360 m)
to the TATR
boundary
(Pillar 872)
3.87 km sambar (8)
leopard (2)
tiger (3)
chital (9)
nilgai (1)
hyaena (3)
civet (3)
sloth bear (6)
common langur (many)
Transect # 2 258, 262,
234, 232
79 30' 20.29 N
20 16' 14.51 E

79 31' 24.75 N
20 18' 01.28 E

TATR boundary
(Pillar 868)
to the end of
the proposed
dam site
(the end point)
3.79 km tiger (1)
nilgai (3)
chital (7)
chowsingha (3)
sloth bear (5)
civet (5)
sambar (3)
hare (1)
common langur (many)
Transect # 3 232 79 32' 19.83 N
20 19' 12.76 E
From the
270 m mark
on the dam
site (the take
off point of
the left bank
canal) till the
point that the
canal comes
out of the
forest)
1.5 km chital (5)
civet (2)
jackal (1)
leopard (1)
chowsingha (3)
common langur (many)
Transect # 4 47, 48 79 32' 17.11 N
20 20' 12.43 E

79 32' 23.77 N
20 19' 20.58 E

From the old
bund to the 0
point of the
dam
1.61 km wild boar (1)
common langur (>7)
chital (4)
chowsingha (1)
sambar (2)
Transect # 5 - 79 29' 11.17 N
20 21' 10.37 E

79 32' 11.60 N
20 19' 01.87 E

Started from
Paarna village
and walked
along the
west bank
of Human
river till the
dam site
6.57 km tiger (5)
leopard (1)
chital (15)
civet (5)
sloth bear (3)
sambar (8)
common langur (>17)

 

Table 9. Mammals recorded from the Proposed Project site

ORDER: Artiodactyla: Even-toed Ungulates  
Family: Bovidae: Bovids  
Nilgai Boselaphus tragocamelus
Four-horned antelope/Chawsingha Tetracerus quadricornis
Family: Cervidae: Deer  
Cheetal/Spotted deer  Axis axis
Sambar Cervus unicolor
   
Family: Suidae: Pigs  
Indian wild boar  Sus scrofa
ORDER: Carnivora: Carnivores  
Family: Canidae: Canines/Dogs  
Jackal  Canis aureus
Wolf Canis lupus
Family: Felidae: Felines/Cats  
Leopard Panthera pardus
Tiger Panthera tigris
Jungle cat Felis chaus
Family: Herpestidae: Mongooses  
Mongoose  Herpestes species
Family: Hyaenidae: Hyaenas  
Striped hyaena Hyaena hyaena
Family: Ursidae: Bears  
Sloth Bear Ursus ursinus
Family: Viverridae: Civets  
Civets Paradoxurus species
ORDER: Lagomorpha: Hares, Rabbits, Pikas  
Family: Leporidae: Hares  
Indian hare/Blacknaped hare  Lepus nigricollis
ORDER: Primates  
Family: Cercopithecidae: Old World Monkeys  
Common langur Semnopithecus entellus
ORDER: Rodentia  
Family: Hystricidae: Old World Porcupines  
Indian porcupine Hystrix indica

 

Table 10. Birds recorded from the Proposed Project site (Taxonomy followed: Manakadan & Pittie, 2001)

Family: Phalacrocoracidae  
Little Cormorant Phalacrocorax niger
Great Cormorant Phalacrocorax carbo
   
Family: Ardeidae  
Little Egret Egretta garzetta
Cattle Egret Bubulcus ibis
Indian Pond-Heron Ardeola grayii
   
Family: Accipitridae  
Black-shouldered Kite Elanus caeruleus
Black Kite Milvus migrans
Shikra Accipiter badius
   
Family: Phasianidae  
Grey Francolin Francolinus pondicerianus
Indian Peafowl  Pavo cristatus
   
Family: Charadriidae  
Red-watttled Lapwing Vanellus indicus
   
Family: Scolopacidae  
Green Sandpiper Tringa ochropus
Common Sandpiper Actitis hypoleucos
   
Family: Columbidae  
Blue Rock Pigeon Columba livia
Little Brown Dove Streptopelia senegalensis
Spotted Dove Streptopelia chinensis
Eurasian Collared-Dove Streptopelia decaocto
   
Family: Psittacidae  
Rose-ringed Parakeet Psittacula krameri
Plum-headed Parakeet Psittacula cyanocephala
   
Family: Cuculidae  
Common Hawk-Cuckoo Hierococcyx varius
Asian Koel  Eudynamys scolopacea
Greater Coucal Centropus sinensis
   
Family: Strigidae  
Jungle Owlet  Glaucidium radiatum
Spotted Owlet Athene brama
   
Family: Apodidae  
House Swift Apus affinis
   
Family: Alcedinidae  
Small Blue Kingfisher Alcedo atthis
White-breasted Kingfisher Halcyon smyrnensis
Lesser Pied Kingfisher Ceryle rudis
   
Family: Meropidae  
Small Green Bee-eater Merops orientalis
   
Family: Coraciidae  
Indian Roller Coracias benghalensis
   
Family: Upupidae  
Common Hoopoe Upupa epops
   
Family: Bucerotidae  
Indian Grey Hornbill Ocyceros birostris
   
Family: Capitonidae  
Coppersmith Barbet  Megalaima haemacephala
   
Family: Picidae  
Yellow-fronted Pied Woodpecker Dendrocopos mahrattensis
Lesser Golden-backed Woodpecker  Dinopium benghalense
Black-backed Woodpecker Chrysocolaptes festivus
   
Family: Hirundinidae  
Dusky Crag-Martin Hirundo concolor
Red-rumped Swallow Hirundo daurica
   
Family: Motacillidae  
White Wagtail  Motacilla alba
Large Pied Wagtail  Motacilla maderaspatensis
Grey Wagtail Motacilla cinerea
Paddyfield Pipit Anthus rufulus
   
Family: Campephagidae  
Large Cuckoo-Shrike Coracina macei
Small Minivet  Pericrocotus cinnamomeus
Common Woodshrike Tephrodornis pondicerianus
   
Family: Pycnonotidae  
Red-vented Bulbul Pycnonotus cafer
   
Family: Irenidae  
Common Iora Aegithina tiphia
   
Family: Laniidae  
Rufous-backed Shrike  Lanius schach
   
Family: Muscicapidae  
Oriental Magpie-Robin Copsychus saularis
Indian Robin  Saxicoloides fulicata
Jungle Babbler  Turdoides striatus
Ashy Prinia Prinia socialis
Blyth’s Reed-Warbler Acrocephalus dumetorum
Common Tailorbird  Orthotomus sutorius
Greenish Leaf-Warbler  Phylloscopus trochiloides
Red-throated Flycatcher  Ficedula parva
Tickell’s Blue-Flycatcher Cyornis tickelliae
White-browed Fantail-Flycatcher  Rhipidura aureola
   
Family: Paridae  
Great Tit Parus major
   
Family: Dicaeidae  
Thick-billed Flowerpecker  Dicaeum agile
   
Family: Nectariniidae  
Purple Sunbird Nectarinia asiatica
   
Family: Zosteropidae  
Oriental White-eye  Zosterops palpebrosus
   
Family: Passeridae  
House Sparrow  Passer domesticus
Yellow-throated Sparrow Petronia xanthocollis
Baya Weaver Ploceus philippinus
   
Family: Sturnidae  
Brahminy Starling Sturnus pagodarum
Common Myna Acridotheres tristis
   
Family: Oriolidae  
Black-headed Oriole Oriolus xanthornus
   
Family: Dicruridae  
Black Drongo  Dicrurus macrocercus
   
Family: Corvidae  
Indian Treepie Dendrocitta vagabunda
Jungle Crow  Corvus macrorhynchos

 

Table 11. Reptiles recorded from the proposed Project site (Taxonomy followed: Das, 1997)
 

Family: Agamidae  
Indian garden lizard Calotes versicolor
South Indian rock agama  Psammophilus dorsalis
Fan-throated lizard Sitana ponticeriana
   
Family: Scincidae  
Skink  Lygosoma sp.
Keeled grass skink Mabuya carinata
   
Family: Lacertidae  
Lacerta Ophisops sp.
   
Family: Varanidae  
Bengal monitor Varanus bengalensis
   
Family: Colubridae  
Indian rat snake Ptyas mucosus
   
Family: Elapidae  
Cobra Naja naja